Insights

Field notes on hiring and AI, from someone who gets paid to decide who's worth the call.

Chicago replaced agencies with Grok Bot agents. Melbourne kept recruiters to pre-vet.

A Chicago fintech CEO, a Melbourne AI software CEO and a UK pharma recruiting specialist on what a fee still buys once AI does the finding.

Chicago replaced agencies with Grok Bot agents. Melbourne kept recruiters to pre-vet.

A Chicago CEO says "We've basically stopped paying for recruiting" and points to a team of Grok Bot agents.

A Melbourne CEO still hands recruiters the search and asks them to pre-vet. Same AI. Opposite invoice.

Then a UK pharma specialist adds a warning: two people can share a job title and have done completely different work. Software sees the title.

So what is a recruiting fee actually buying now? Three leaders, three answers, one uncomfortable invoice.

We asked founders and hiring leaders whether AI should push recruiting fees down, and what they are actually paying for. If software can find the candidates, what is left on the invoice? These three answered with specifics, and they don't line up.

Sourcing went to the bots. So did the fee.

Peter Hwang, Founder & CEO of Amplify Tech Labs (Chicago, United States)

“We've basically stopped paying for recruiting, and I don't expect that to change. AI is the reason. I use a team of dedicated Grok Bot agents, to search LinkedIn for developer candidates for me and to track every reply and message, so sourcing and follow-up no longer need an agency.”

Peter Hwang

“What AI hasn't replaced is vetting, and that's the only thing I'd still pay for. Of every 100 engineers who apply to Amplify Tech Labs, 3 make it through our five stages, including a live business case and a live technical case where we watch how someone reasons about money.”

Peter Hwang

Read the order. Sourcing and follow-up went to the agents, and the fee went with them. His verdict on the old model is short: "A percentage of salary for sending résumés, no." Vetting is the line he still respects. AI-first, but not judgment-free.

Chicago said goodbye. Melbourne said please pre-vet.

Jonas Christensen, CEO of ExpandIQ (Greater Melbourne Area, Australia)

“Having helped recruitment firms with their AI strategy, I see databases of CVs and profiles that go stale the moment someone changes jobs.”

Jonas Christensen

“We didn't have the capacity to find them ourselves, so we chose recruiters we trusted to find and pre-vet candidates who fit exactly what we asked for.”

Jonas Christensen

He has seen recruiting from the inside, helping recruitment firms with AI strategy, and still bought the service. Capacity was the reason and trust was the filter. His own summary: "Sourcing is automatable. Picking the right person isn't."

Same title, completely different job.

Chris Stirling, Managing Director of Stirling Q&R (Crawley, United Kingdom)

“In Quality and Regulatory hiring for pharma, biotech and medical devices, two people with the same title can have completely different scope. One Head of Quality built a full QMS and led notified body audits, another signed off documents someone else wrote. AI reads the title. A specialist asks what they actually did.”

Chris Stirling

The follow-up question is the whole product. In a small biotech, "audit findings and a late submission" can follow a weak first hire. He says that bill dwarfs any fee saved.

Your turn

If you hire, what would you still pay a recruiter for now that AI can source?

Next: an Indian fractional CTO, a Texas founder and a Bangkok medical-travel founder each price a bad hire, from $15,000 in lost salary to $350,000+ in broken architecture, and all three say the fee is the wrong number to cut.

Tags
Was this useful?

Know before you hire.

One email when a new field note is out.